Can A 301 Redirect Be a Bad Idea For Your Website?
What Is A Redirect?
A redirect, in website terminology, is the process of forwarding, or otherwise pointing a URL and the associated page content to a different URL. There are quite a few methods of URL redirection, but these three are the most commonly used:
- 301 Redirect – “Moved Permanently”
- 302 Redirect – “Moved Temporarily” (Also called “Found Redirects” in later versions of HTTP)
- Meta Refresh – Page-Level Redirect
We’ll be focusing on 301 redirects today, but it’s important to understand the differences between these methods.
302 Temporary Redirects, as the name implies, allows a site to temporarily point a URL to a different URL, commonly used in cases where the homepage or original page may be under construction, or a category on an eCommerce page that has no currently active products. These redirects do not pass link juice and are not intended to be permanent, so their use should be limited to specific use cases where a temporary page is necessary.
Meta Refresh Redirects are a different method of achieving a redirect, only the actual redirection process takes place at the page level, not the server level. You’ve likely encountered a meta refresh redirect if you’ve ever visited a site with a splash page with a message similar to:
“If you are not redirected to a different page in 10 seconds, click here.”
This page is performing a redirect after loading the original URL, instead of replacing it entirely. These do pass some link authority to the new page URL, but they are not recommended because of their poor user experience, and the fact that these redirects do not pass full authority in the same way as a 301 redirect does.
Now that we’ve covered how the basic types of redirects work, let’s take a closer look at 301 redirects.
How Could A 301 Redirect Be A Bad Idea?
When you are making major structural changes for a new website, ensuring that you’ve gracefully depreciated any old URLs or old pages is essential. A lot of people will tell you that using 301 redirects on all removed URLs is the best way to stay on Google’s good side in terms of the 301 redirect strategy. The SEO pros at Moz agree:
A 301 redirect is a permanent redirect which passes between 90-99% of link juice (ranking power) to the redirected page. 301 refers to the HTTP status code for this type of redirect. In most instances, the 301 redirect is the best method for implementing redirects on a website.
However, sometimes a permanent 301 redirect can be a less-than-ideal solution.
Not All Pages Deserve A 301 Redirect
If you have a relevant page with decent link juice behind it that’s receiving a decent amount of traffic from organic or garnering quality external links, it’s in your best interest to pass that link juice to a new corresponding web page within your revised structure using a 301 redirect. But if we’re talking about rarely visited pages or old pages that no longer serve a real function, it’s okay to let those old ones 404 and drop from Google’s index. This won’t negatively affect SEO.
Too Many 301 Redirects Can Hurt Your Website
Redirect loops and link-hopping are known spam tactics, and as a result, you run the risk of your SEO efforts being penalized by Google’s search engine bias for low-quality page content if the proportion of redirects to indexed pages is too high. 301s also dampen site performance, which can be detrimental to both user experience, and page rank.
If you have an equivalent piece of content that matches the page you’re replacing well, then a 301 redirect is usually your best option to avoid keyword cannibalization. But in a case where the content may only tangentially relate to the new URL, such as top-level category pages for an eCommerce store, it may be best to let that page fall out of your index to allow search engines to find the new page organically and rank you accordingly.
Stay Connected to UpCity
Subscribe to our blog for monthly updates on best-practices, guides, and more for B2B service providers.
Sometimes, Letting Go Is The Best 301 Redirect Strategy
Allowing old pages to drop out of the index can afford you the opportunity to build an entirely new, better-optimized replacement that is up-to-date and consistent with the latest Google algorithm changes and guidelines. So, next time you’re migrating a new site structure or just cleaning the house and removing old pages and content, think twice when building your 301 redirect strategy, and remember: Sometimes it’s okay to let go. Really. It’s okay.
About the author
Rebecca helps keep all things content running at UpCity. Prior to joining, she was a magazine editor at an agency for several award-winning publications based in the Minneapolis-St. Paul area, and a content specialist for several brands within the SMB/B2B landscape. She also has significant experience in digital content creation, most notably targeting hunters and anglers (despite being a vegetarian) during her time at Gander Outdoors. Rebecca has also worked in PR, covering a diverse terrain of products and events, including the promotion of local musicians and music festivals and the latest craft beer offerings from local breweries.